2026 Recommended Pizza Spots in Oahu, Hawaii

In 2026, the culinary scene in Oahu is all about the "Farm-to-Table" movement. Pizzerias are leading the charge by incorporating locally grown tomatoes, artisanal goat cheese, and fresh island pineapples into their recipes. From casual street-side slices to sophisticated wood-fired ovens in upscale dining rooms, Hawaii's pizza game has reached a new level of excellence. Enhance your foodie journey by checking WAUG for exclusive meal vouchers and nearby island activities.

 

01. J. Dolan's

A legendary establishment in Downtown Honolulu, J. Dolan's remains the undisputed king of New York-style pizza in Hawaii for 2026. This Irish-themed pub offers a thin, crispy, yet remarkably chewy crust that stands up to their rich, house-made tomato sauce. It’s the perfect spot to unwind after a WAUG historic city tour. Don't miss the 'Giacomo,' their signature pie loaded with spicy pepperoni, sausage, and aromatic herbs that creates a perfect symphony of flavors when paired with a cold local craft beer.

 

02. Appetito Craft Pizza & Wine Bar

Located conveniently on the ground floor of the Ohana Waikiki East Hotel, this chic eatery specializes in authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas baked in a high-temperature wood-fired oven. In 2026, their 'Porcini Mushroom Pizza'—drizzled with premium truffle oil—has become a viral sensation for its earthy aroma and Instagram-worthy presentation. With an extensive wine list and an elegant, modern atmosphere, it is the premier choice for a romantic date night or a high-end dinner after a day of beach hopping in Waikiki.

 

03. The Pizza Press

A rapidly growing favorite in the Kapolei and Pearl City areas, this 1920s newspaper-themed pizzeria offers a unique "Publish Your Own" experience. Much like a high-end assembly line, you can choose unlimited fresh toppings, various sauces, and specialized doughs for one flat price. In 2026, it is the top-rated spot for travelers looking for the best value without compromising on quality. It's an ideal stop after a WAUG golf session at Ko Olina or a shopping spree at Waikele, especially if you try 'The Editor'—a creative take on the Hawaiian pizza featuring spicy jalapeños.